EBR Comment 5

Subject: Fw: Fall bird count discrepancies between Horizon’s REA and Thunder Cape

Dear Ms Raetsen:

I have listed below the discrepancies between fall bird counts (section 4.3) in Horizon Wind’s draft REA  Avian Impact Assessment and the fall bird counts from Thunder Cape Bird Observatory on the same coastline mountain range as the proposed wind farm.  The numbers are so low, that it would lead one to believe that this point survey is also totally inadequate and not credible.  Thunder Cape’s daily estimated total (DET) is derived from a combination of census, total number of birds banded and incidental observations throughout the day.

Horizon’s fall raptor survey states that there was 108 hours of observation over 18 different count days.  Again, Horizon could “not locate or employ the services of a highly qualified bird surveyor who was available and willing to undertake the surveys when required.”  Therefore, “a skilled outdoors person equipped with high quality recording gear was enlisted to carry out a series of point counts.”  Is this a joke?

Further, Horizon states that “the Big Thunder site consists of a large forested area of rocky and sharply variable terrain, most of it only accessible on foot and by difficult navigation through dense forest into isolated areas.”  This means that a thorough study was too difficult, so they settled for an inept, inadequate bird survey.  Surveys of this type may serve Environment Canada’s protocol for truly remote sites, perhaps on the Canadian Shield 500 km north of Thunder Bay with no road access, but the Big Thunder site is about 3 km from my home and a few hundred metres from a ski hill within a township.  There is no excuse for this.

Here are the fall bird count comparisons:

Thunder Cape Bird Observatory (DET)             Horizon’s Avian Impact Assessment

Ruby-throated Hummingbird                     74.6                            1

Yellow-bellied Sapsucker                                24.9                            6

Downy Woodpecker                                          1132.9                         18

Hairy Woodpecker                                             110.8                             2

Northern Flicker                                                  152                             10

Pileated Woodpecker                                        27.3                          17

Least Flycatcher                                                  36.8                             2

Northern Shrike                                                  100                               1

Red-eyed Vireo                                                     155                                8

Blue Jay                                                                 1254.9                         65

Common Raven                                                 501.1                         211

Black-capped Chickadee                             3844.1                       56

Red-breasted Nuthatch                              1195.6                         81

Ruby-crowned Kinglet                                 369.8                          4

Swainson’s Thrush                                       328.8                            2

American Robin                                          1752.8                            30

Black-throated Blue Warbler                 24.4                                1

Black-throated Green Warbler             182.4                               3

American Redstart                                        660.4                             1

White-throated Sparrow                          188.9                                3

Snow Bunting                                               222.6                                  14

Pine Grosbeak                                             42.3                                      31

Purple Finch                                               399.9                                     3

Pine Siskin                                                  2940.3                                   218

American Goldfinch                             239.6                                     19

These bird counts in all but one case, do not look representative of the true bird population of the region’s mountain range / escarpment.  How can Horizon accurately state in their draft REA that “There are no Important Bird Areas within the range of influence of the Big Thunder Wind Farm Site”?  They are basing this statement on inaccurate data.

The MOE must reject this project!!!  There are so many reasons why, the avian impact assessment being just one of them.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s